***Update 1 – 2017-05-01 – 11:45 CEST***

As you might remember. Late last night I said that I got in contact with OpenCritic for a comment about Paul Ryan’s statement about OpenCritic using Brash Games as a scapegoat for their own personal gain. Well, this is what OpenCritic had to say about that matter:

“Hi there Matthew =)

I don’t know if you’re aware of this, but it seems like Brash Games Paul Ryan is accusing OpenCritic for using Brash Games as a scapegoat to fuel their own success:
http://thegg.net/opinion-editorial/brash-games-blames-their-recent-scandals-on-ex-writers-and-opencritic-the-victim-and-scapegoat-card-has-been-played/

So I just wanted to check with you if you have any comment on that matter?” Robin Ek, TGG

And this was the response that I received from OpenCritic:

“We stand by our report. Our motivation in publishing the report was to meet our commitment to the gaming community to investigate and report wrongdoing by official publications, as outlined in our FAQ. Brash Games was aware of this process when they joined OpenCritic in December 2016:

The ethics requirement is the most subjective requirement that we have, and we hope never to use as a basis for removal. If we ever do determine that an outlet is in violation of ethical codes, we will conduct our own investigation. We require that there be a clear violation that compromises the entire publication’s ability to objectively review games, with supporting evidence that proves the violation beyond a reasonable doubt. If we do conduct an investigation, we will not suspend review content during that investigation, and we will make a public statement at the conclusion. For questions about what constitutes basic ethics, we go by the Society of Professional Journalism Code of Ethics.

Contrary to Brash’s claim, at no point did we state or even imply a motive for changing scores. Our report also states that “we stress that incidents may have been rare.” We still do not know why Brash has changed the scores without the consent of the author, but seven independent critics made the claim, with more joining after the report’s release.

In the end, OpenCritic is not making the allegations – numerous independent critics are. We gave Brash numerous chances to respond to the substance of the multiple allegations against them, at times even pleading with them to apologize and make amends. Instead, Brash chose to try to deflect and delete evidence.

OpenCritic has been growing since our launch in September 2015 solely due to the support of the gaming community. Our mission is to improve the gaming industry for everyone: critics, developers, and gamers alike. We won’t always be perfect, but we strive to continue to earn the community’s trust and support.” Matthew Enthoven, OpenCritic

So there you have it folks. I am yet to hear Paul Ryan’s side of the story though (I e-mailed him last night). So I hope to hear from him soon.
————————————————–

I (Robin Ek, TGG) had a feeling that Brash Games’s Paul Ryan (owner, PR-manager and review-code manager) would make his grand return to games industry in a very near future, and that Ryan would try to make it sound like he and Brash Games were the “real” victim in the story about Brash Games and their shady business practices and total lack of moral and ethics. Because in Ryan’s world nothings more important than to reach the “Things are back to normal now” status as soon as possible.  Even so, I was still surprised to hear that Paul Ryan would play out the victim and scapegoat card in the way that he did. You see, in Brash Games post “Brash Games Statement – Not So Open Critic” Ryan not only took a swing at OpenCritic and ex-Brash Games writers, he also managed to squeeze in his physical health status (Ryan uses a wheelchair) into the mix as well (as seen in the pictures down below):

“I acknowledge I made mistakes in deleting the accounts of some previous volunteers and would like to take this opportunity to personally apologise to those concerned for my actions. I am deeply sorry for my actions and I will be reinstating the effected accounts as soon as possible. I would like the effected parties to contact me via the contact form with a list of articles and the URL’s so I can re-instate the accounts with immediate effect.

I have already added several accounts and am waiting for others contributors to get in touch. With regards to changing review scores this has been completely blown out of proportion by Open Critic who were not interested in the truth, despite the stats on Metacritic that prove otherwise. According to Metacritic on average, Brash Games grades 4.5 points lower than other critics. Open Critic made out that we were actually changing review scores to please publishers but the evidence says otherwise.”

“So why did Open Critic make such a meal of it ? They wanted to use Brash Games and this so-called scandal as a springboard to announce themselves to the gaming community (GamersGate style), after all their previous attempts had failed. They were shunned by publishers, developers and the gaming public. That’s why they started to drip feeding parts of their so-called investigation on game forums to build momentum and anticipation for the big reveal and to say “Hey look we’re here to weed our corruption and wrongdoing in the games industry”.

An unnamed source told Brash Games “They (Open Critic) had to do something, they had failed to make inroads into the aggregation field and Metacritic was still firmly regarded as the industry standard while Open Critic wasn’t even in the running. So they set about finding a scapegoat, someone who wouldn’t fight back or make a scene, a sacrificial lamb for the slaughter and unfortunately that was Brash Games run by a cripple in a wheelchair, you know the one. Talk about an easy target”. What followed was a game of chinese whispers and suddenly I was responsible for everything, even the air strikes on Syria, no I’m not that Paul Ryan.”

“We have not yer had time to respond in full to Open Critic’s report but will do so in the coming weeks/months.”Brash Games

So even though there have been plenty of articles and videos that have exposed Brash Games shady business practicese in the past, Paul Ryan still manages to play out both the victim and scapegoat card (all while put blaming on others). Well, what can I say really? I mean, the whole thing feels very surreal and twisted. So it’s going to be very interesting to see how OpenCritic and the growing number of ex-Brash Games writers will respond to all of this, and speaking of which. A claimed ex-Brash Games writer called Sean Winnett has claimed that Brash Games removed his authorship just recently (as seen in the second picture down below). In other words, if that’s true, then Brash games removed Winnett’s authorship shortly after their brief statement/apology post

So the story about Brash Games and their actions just keeps on getting more and more bizarre and tasteless for each day that goes by (literally). You know, from my point of view. It seems like Paul Ryan is only sorry that he got caught, and that’s all there is to it. In the matter of fact, things have gone so far with Brash Games and the scandals that currently are surrounding them. That people have started to call Paul Ryan the Paul Feig of video games (Paul Feig blamed everything and everyone but himself for his own failure with the “Ghostbusters 2016” movie). So I’m pretty curious to see what Ryan with come up with next, especially so since his already played out the victim and scapegoat card.

My point would be that Ryan can’t continue to blame everyone and everything for his own mistakes forever, because sooner or later people won’t believe a single thing that he say. Furthermore, he will most likely be called out on his bs as well. Anyways, this is what I got to share on the matter for now. I have also reached out to OpenCritic and Paul Ryan for a comment. So I will update this post once I get a response from either camp.

And with that said, what’s your take on this matter? Let us know your thoughts in the comment section down below!

Credit:
Just Lyle

Source:
Brash Games is an unethical train wreck
Brash Games Statement – Not So Open Critic
Brash Games on Twitter
Respect, Paul Ryan, And The End Of Brash Games

***Disclaimer***
This is a personal opinion of the writer, and it doesn’t necessarily represent the other writers (nor The Gaming Ground´s) opinions.

tgg author avatar robin ek
Robin “V-Act” Ek
Editor in chief
The Gaming Ground
Twitter: @TheGamingGround

Related Posts


More by Robin Ek:

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Save 3$ with our Play-Asia coupon code "thegg"

20 Comments ON " Brash Games blames their recent scandals on ex-wri... "
  • Hey Robin. Just a heads-up, but unless you also post other people’s work under your byline then there is no real reason why you need to follow up every “I” with (Robin Ek, TGG). We know what site we’re on, and we know whose name is on the article, man. Trust me, we can figure that shit out for ourselves. 😛

    • Hi =) Funny enough, I did it like that in the past, but then people told me that it would be a good idea to state who “I” is. Yes, I know, but it’s for clarification purposes. Nope, I don’t post other people’s work in my name. Furthermore, I just write out my name one time in every post that I make.

      • Gotcha, so it’s compensation for other people’s inability to read the byline. 😛

        Thanks for humoring me, dude. I do appreciate the clarification.

        • Pretty much 😉 Np =) You are most welcome 😉

    • Shaun Shaffer

      You’re a goddamn jew.

      • How would you know?

        • Shaun Shaffer

          Anyone who pisses me off is a goddamn jew to me and now I’m going to make your life a living hell.

          • Yeah? Then “maybe” you should take some medication and just chill out a bit? HAHA! Good luck with that one pal, because I already live in hell.

          • Laytonaster

            Aw, man! You just missed the opportunity to use the Navy Seals Copypasta!

          • Don’t worry, the guy will most likely get back at me 😛

  • RifRafferty

    They should just rebrand as “Brash Garbage”

    • I wouldn’t be surprised if Paul Ryan tries a “re-branding” attempt later on.

  • andelbam

    Better to admit that you are in the wrong and start clean. Open Critic has an agenda, a good one.

    • Yes, but Paul Ryan has been doing this “stuff” for a very long time. Furthermore, the scandals just keep on stacking up for each day that goes by (Ryan might even end up in court now).

  • DynastyStar

    Just a little piece of criticism, use spellcheck. Saw plenty of obvious errors here; “yer” instead of yet, “his” instead of he’s, “with” instead of will. I think you meant to say “Gamergate” as in the hashtag not “Gamersgate” as in the game retail store. I can’t be sure on that last one though

    • ” Saw plenty of obvious errors here; “yer”

      – That’s from a quote:

      “We have not yer had time to respond in full to Open Critic’s report but will do so in the coming weeks/months.” – Brash Games

      ” I think you meant to say “Gamergate” as in the hashtag not “Gamersgate” as in the game retail store. I can’t be sure on that last one though”

      – That was not clear at the time, as Paul Ryan wrote a very sloppy post about. However, I think that he meant “#GamerGate”. As for the rest, I already use a spell check service. Even so, I might have missed out on some errors at the time (I work a lot). So I fix everything on the fly when I see it (or when someone points it out for me/us).

      Anyways, thanks for taking your time to leave some feedback to me/us =) You will find our latest giveaways here:
      http://thegg.net/category/giveaways/

Advertising spot

Help us stay alive

Paypal Patreon logo

Google ads (please turn off your adblock)

Advertisement

 

Play-Asia.com - Buy Games & Codes for PS4, PS3, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U and PC / Mac.

 

 

Recent posts

"Syberia 1" is coming to the Switch today, and "Syberia 2" will launch on the 30th of November

"Syberia 1" is coming to the Switch today, and "Syberia 2" will launch on the 30th of November

Press release: Paris, October 19, 2017 – Microids, an international multiplatform video game publis[...]
Blast Out's "Whispers Of The Jungle" update is now available

Blast Out's "Whispers Of The Jungle" update is now available

Tribal Top Down Brawler Adds New Jungle Arena, New Fighter Character, New Gear Pieces and Traits Plu[...]
Halloween is coming to the post-apocalyptic action MMO "Crossout"

Halloween is coming to the post-apocalyptic action MMO "Crossout"

Witch Hunting In Spooky Night Battles. Press release: Thursday, October 19, 2017 — The Halloween[...]
The WW2 strategy simulation game "Bomber Crew" is now available on Steam

The WW2 strategy simulation game "Bomber Crew" is now available on Steam

Press release: London, United Kingdom – October 19th – Brighton-based two man development team Runn[...]
Kirby Battle Royale is coming to 3DS on the 3rd of November in Europe

Kirby Battle Royale is coming to 3DS on the 3rd of November in Europe

As some of you might already know, the "Kirby" series celebrated it's 25th anniversary back in Augus[...]
"Odysseus Kosmos" and "Super Turbo Demon Busters!" is coming to PC this November

"Odysseus Kosmos" and "Super Turbo Demon Busters!" is coming to PC this November

Today is a good day for those who like games with pixel graphics, because we were just informed by H[...]

Google ads

Our sponsors

Kinguin
EwinRacing Calling Series Gaming Chairs
TGG v2.4 © 2014 - 2017 *The Gaming Ground* all rights reserved
twitch icon youtube icon google plus icon twitter icon facebook icon rss icon
alexa
Privacy policy
TGG ethics policies