Hey, have you had enough of the words “Trump” and “GamerGate” being in the same article yet? Me too, but this one is an interesting case. Instead of it being your typical article by someone who claims to be a journalist of video games, this article, titled, “Trump and GamerGate,” is written by Mari Landgrebe, a Business student at Texas State University, courtesy of Study Breaks, a website that is by students, for students. So not your typical article on the subject.

From the subtitle, you can tell that you are in for a treat. She claims that the president-elect is a sign for the resurgence of GamerGate, as if the group was gone in the first place. While the article starts with some rambling about how bad it was to be a millennial in the current year, the real beginning starts with an incorrect summary as to how GamerGate began. As the article states that #GamerGate start was with the Zoey Post, and that GamerGate doxed and harassed Zoey Quinn and other prominent women developers. As anyone who is actually affiliated with GamerGate can tell you, this is incorrect, both the start, and the idea of harassment.

While I know my audience is rather intelligent, and I don’t want to insult their intelligence with a summary of information they are already aware of, I am aware that the audience intended for the original article may find their way here, and I feel they deserve an accurate representation for how the group came to be.

i support gamergate

Simple and Clean (Source: http://teckcomesfirst.com/wp-content/uploads/1xt7zxn.png).

While, yes, the Zoey post was one of the multitude of matches that started the fire. However, a fire cannot light without fuel, and the fuel came in the form of the August 28th, where a number of websites that claim to be for the gaming industry began attacking their audience. It was a reaction to the attacks on what was a silent audience. It was never about race, sex, or the like, as anyone in GamerGate can tell you that anyone is welcome in video games. The group has since grown, taking over a number of issues such as politics being forced into our hobby and censorship from people who, as many in GamerGate see, aren’t doing their jobs. What brings us to the group may differ, but the core group was never about keeping games white or male or doxing people who try to change games.

Make note, I will not make the claim that there aren’t people in GG who are guilty of these terrible acts, as I will not be guilty of the “No-True-Scotsman” fallacy. It must be known that this is not the norm. Once is too many, and those who commit these crimes are looked down upon and condemned by the majority.

With that off my chest, I can continue. The writer thinks GG to be a bunch of boys and men who want to see sexy women with no people of color in “history, space or fantasy”. I’ve already explained why this is incorrect, so let’s move on. The author believes this supposed racism to be what brings a lot of them to Trump, even though the vast majority of GG has been shown to be Libertarian-Left on the Political Compass test.

gamergate political compass

This is starting to become a staple in my GamerGate posts . (Source: http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/841/842/7e1.png).

gamergate life part 7 kukuruyo

You know, it’d be kind of weird that a bunch of “misogynists” would pick a female to be the mascot of their group. (Source: http://kukuruyo.com/comic/gamergate-life-7/).

Nevertheless, the main issue I have with this article is that through the vast majority of it, it tries to do what a lot of journalists have already done, demonize the gamer name. The idea that gamers are drawn to Trump because of racism is insane, and that Trump’s appointment of Milo Yiannopoulos is a sign of endorsement of GG even though Trump himself has gone on record saying that video games create monsters, and something has to be done shows a disconnect in the true state of how things are.

donald trump vs violent video games

A point I disagree with more than any other. (Source: http://i.imgur.com/sJ0WVyo.jpg).

The rest of the article is trying to find a number of different names to call GG in order to sling mud, as if gamers haven’t seen enough mud to drown in thus far. It has the typical usages of “dude-bro” and “man-children” which I’ve seen so many times. I’ve developed a permanent condition where my eyes are perpetually rolling. This article is nothing new. It makes it feel like this is the stand of an author who wants to get in good by attacking an easy target.

However, I won’t call the author names. I’m honestly nonchalant about it because it’s something I see every day and only shows a lack of originality, which is not an insult, but rather a point that there needs to be new discussion amongst journalists. What is weird, however, is that although the author makes these bold accusations (which we’ve all heard a dozen times). Even so, the article doesn’t show us any real evidence. As the links provided in the article simply take the user to Polygon, Wikipedia, Kotaku and other websites that GG has had a long history combating.

The sources show a surplus of confirmation bias on the author’s part. If the author wishes to continue working in journalism, it will be important for them to learn about these research mistakes. What does bother me is a failure to research things from all angles. Before I wanted anything to do with GG, I wanted to make sure I was well-informed on their goals and way of handling things. Once I saw that they were rightfully disgruntled consumers, I made my decision. Nothing that bothers me more than a poor-informed choice, and the fact that the article shows a very low-level of research on the other side, it makes me believe they jumped the bandwagon as soon as it rolled by.

If the author had shown some initiative and tried to see things from another angle, I probably would have left it alone. However, this level of confirmation bias is extremely strong and needs to be talked about. Why not talk about the dozens of charities GG has supported and sponsored? Why not talk about how GG supported the Fine Young Capitalists’ attempt to promote women in the games’ industry? There is so much that can be said, and the big connection to Trump, as promised, by the subtitle?

It never happens. It’s like the article set out on being the groundbreaking piece being the nail in the coffin of GG, but it never comes to light. There is so little connection to Trump and seems to be just someone getting upset that GG is a thing. It’s almost frustrating. As it makes it really hard to write about the article…Honestly, it´s because it promises so much, but all it does in the end is to make a bunch of points and tries desperately to connect them only to fail. What else can I say about this article? I can only wish that this article had an actual point to debunk instead of a list of accusations that were already debunked two years ago.

Source:
Studybreaks
Gamers are dead articles
Gameobjective

Credit:
Robin Ek – Editor
Just Lyle ‏

***Disclaimer***
This is a personal opinion of the writer, and it doesn’t necessarily represent the other writers (nor The Gaming Ground´s) opinions.

***Disclosure***
I’m pro-GG supporter, and I think that Trump is more favorable than Clinton between the two candidates.

tgg author avatar Jay Shay
Justin Easler
Senior editor
The Gaming Ground
Twitter: @masterjayshay

Related Posts


More by Justin Easler:

Tags: , , , , ,

EwinRacing Calling Series Gaming Chairs

Save 3$ with our Play-Asia coupon code "thegg"

10 Comments ON " A response to Study Breaks “Trump and GamerG... "
  • Spider Jerusalem

    It’s just another rehash of the old Guilt by Association tripe.

    Milo once built his career on GamerGate, now he has a career telling everyone how great Trump is.

    GamerGate hung out on 4chan, people on one single board on 4chan was very pro-Trump during the elections.

    GamerGate hung out on 8chan after getting censored to hell and banned on 4chan and because some less savory characters also used 8chan, GamerGate was pro-doxing and pro-pedophilia.

    Ergo GamerGate is pro-Trump, pro-doxing and pro-pedophilia according to this “logic”.

    No matter how many times you take it out for a spin, it’s still a logical fallacy.

    • Jay Shay

      Agreed

  • Nanya

    Yes Trump said one bad thing about Vidya.

    He hasn’t said anything about Vidya other than that one post.

    I don’t recall him trying to lobby for games to be banned like Hillary did.

    • Jay Shay

      Don’t get me wrong. I think the past is the past. I just used that as an example of how little research went into her article.

      • Nanya

        Fair enough, and I agree with you. People can make mistakes and change based on new information.

        Some, however, don’t change no matter what.

        • “Some, however, don’t change no matter what.”

          And we are finding out that this is 99% of SJWs and feminists, with the 1% being people like Cassie Jaye

        • Jay Shay

          Agreed.

      • lol, since when do SJWs put research into their articles?

        They either make it up as they go along or only provide “research” that is biased and heavily skewed towards their favour.

        • Jay Shay

          How can these people be taken so seriously in the academic sphere? My school invited an anti-aging person to speak and her “evidence” of harassment came from egg accounts that didn’t even use the hashtag and never used the hashtag.

          • These people are taken seriously because society, politics and government allow it too: the society that allow it are the white-knights, manginas, male feminists and cucks; the politics push the ideology; and the government makes it law.

            The students themselves are indoctrinated at very young ages in school, with an ideology that is based on feminism. Basically: boys/men = bad; girls/women = good, Caucasian = bad; Any other race = good

            These people then go into college/university with that ideology, and take up courses which enhance the ideology so they can pick up a degree for it. That’s why we’re getting these Safe Spaces, feminists and race baiters.

            Then there’s also the matter of finances, which the students actually pay a lot of money for these Social Justice “gender studies” type courses. Therefore the academics will do everything to maintain these courses.

            Then you have retards like Anita Sarkeesian and Jonathan Mcintosh.

            Basically, remember like 15-20 years ago when SJWs/feminists/activists/etc. used to like campaign out on the streets every now and then? We all used to ignore them and call them crazy. These people are now the teachers and professors in academia. So there you go.

            It’s going to take 10 years minimum to undo this slew of SJW faeces.

Advertising spot

Help us stay alive

Paypal Patreon logo

Google ads (please turn off your adblock)

Advertisement

 

Play-Asia.com - Buy Games & Codes for PS4, PS3, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U and PC / Mac.

 

 

Recent posts

Judas Priest just got their very own mobile game - Say hello to "Road To Valhalla"

Judas Priest just got their very own mobile game - Say hello to "Road To Valhalla"

I really love the fact that I was just listening to Judas Priest (Live in Miami 1988, to be exact) w[...]
Sudden Strike 4 gets reversible cover art by "Game of Thrones" artist

Sudden Strike 4 gets reversible cover art by "Game of Thrones" artist

Propaganda-inspired Artwork Designed by Renowned Artist Robert Simon Available for Sudden Strike 4 o[...]
NetherWorld - A very brutal and naughty upcoming 2D adventure game

NetherWorld - A very brutal and naughty upcoming 2D adventure game

I (Robin Ek, TGG) just found out about a truly promising and cool looking 2D adventure game called "[...]
Warframe's "Chains of Harrow" update is coming to PS4 and Xbox One today

Warframe's "Chains of Harrow" update is coming to PS4 and Xbox One today

Emerging from the Darkness, the Harrow Update Arrives With New Warframe, Quest, Weapons, Enemies, an[...]
The Banner Saga complete pack PS4 review - A neat fantasy tactical RPG that suffers from some rough edges

The Banner Saga complete pack PS4 review - A neat fantasy tactical RPG that suffers from some rough edges

"The Banner Saga" is the work of a team of ex-BioWare developers called Stoic, and although you migh[...]
No70: Eye of Basir PC review - A rather good first-person horror adventure/puzzle game

No70: Eye of Basir PC review - A rather good first-person horror adventure/puzzle game

Living in a haunted house may sound bad but being dragged into a supernatural investigation because [...]

Google ads

Our sponsors

Kinguin
EwinRacing Calling Series Gaming Chairs
TGG v2.4 © 2014 - 2017 *The Gaming Ground* all rights reserved
twitch icon youtube icon google plus icon twitter icon facebook icon rss icon
alexa
Privacy policy
TGG ethics policies