It has recently been revealed that Criminal Girls 2 will be coming to the western market in a censored form. And censorship is a hot topic that has people split on the idea. Censorship has also raised an important question. And that would be if it´s better to get the game in question but in a cut-up form, or not get the game at all if it is not 100% of the original? I´ll leave you with that question for now (I will return to that subject later on), because I want to discuss the idea of reviewing censored games. I mean, should these games even get a score, and if so how?

Well, please allow me to give you an example. I reviewed Criminal Girls 1 last year, and funny enough the censorship made the game worse in terms of what it was trying to block. I gave the game a score. Should I have? As censorship, by definition, cuts out content. We are not talking about an update to fix something like spelling or a bug preventing a person from opening a door. Censorship removes the door. No one can experience what is behind the door.

criminal girls 2 nis america four changes

I bet that “Criminal Girls 2” will get even further censorship in the West.

I would also like to point out that game reviews are a controversial issue on its own, because a lot of the time the issues have everything to do with the review score itself. And that´s due to the fact that games which the masses think are 10s get a lot of press, when one random outlet gives it a 7 (see “Uncharted”). Hell, some sites have done away with scores altogether, but those are few and far between because they are already major sites that are established on the Gaming market. And since a lot of smaller sites need scores to survive because being on an aggregate like Metacritic gets them traffic. Well, simply put, no score, no Metacritic and no more boost in hits.

However, as the awareness of censorship in games is becoming more available, my thoughts on review scores are in flux. Because I think that if the game in question is incomplete, then it shouldn’t get a full score. Because censorship makes a complete game unfinished, as censorship = Removing content from a complete product. So, are the companies giving us a discount for the missing content that another country is getting automatically? No, because we have to pay for DLC a lot of the time for additional content, and that makes me wonder why there is no discount on content taken away? (corporate greed, I guess).

fire emblem fates petting

Is there anything that won´t get censored nowadays?

Speaking of censorship, Fire Emblem: Fates will go down in history as a tainted title because of censorship. Just the petting mini-game alone made a lot of Gamers angry, as the petting mini-game was ripped out entirely from the Western release. And that part is a major piece of content which gamers are prevented from enjoying. However, the petting mini-game is to be found in the Japanese version of “Fire Emblem: Fates”, so why shouldn’t there be a penalty associated with the missing content in the Western version? Allow me to give you another example.

When I give my students a test, and they don’t answer a question, I don’t reduce the max score from a 10 to a 9, so they can still get a perfect score. No, my students get a 9/10 score if everything else is correct. At the same time, I still believe that not giving a censored game a score entirely is too extreme, because hack jobs like “Fire Emblem: Fates” is the extreme and not the norm. Nevertheless, reviewers performing the above example, knocking off points for censorship, are what should be done. So, will that happen? Probably not, because review scores are down to the individual reviewing the game.

Even so, the masses still like to put all the credit and blame of a review score on a website, but in reality, it is the individual reviewer who should be getting all the credit and blame. Unless a mass of reviewers band together and make up a universal scoring rubric that will be adhered to by their websites, then don’t expect anything to change in the near future.

And with that said, what´s your take on this matter? Let me know your thoughts in the comment section down below!

Credit:
Robin Ek – Editor

 ***Disclaimer***
This is a personal opinion of the writer, and it doesn’t necessarily represent the other writers (nor The Gaming Ground´s) opinions.

Dane Smith
The Gaming Ground
Twitter: @LasombraFiles

More by Robin Ek:

Tags: , , , , ,

Nutaku booty calls 728px 90px banner
Nutaku celebrate hentai
´
26 Comments ON " Video game censorship – The idea of reviewin... "

TGG categories

Advertising spot

Erogames boobs in the city 160 x 600 px banner

Help us stay alive

Patreon logo

Paypal

Patreon logo

Join our server on Discord

Discord

Advertising spot

nutaku booty calls 160 x 600 px banner

Advertisement

 

 

 

nutaku booty calls 160 x 600 px banner

Recent posts

Apogee has just accepted a 5-million USD investment by eWTP Tech Innovation Fund

Apogee has just accepted a 5-million USD investment by eWTP Tech Innovation Fund

Press release: DALLAS — January 25, 2022. Apogee Entertainment, the legendary developer-publisher be[...]
The story-driven ARPG “No Place for Bravery” is coming to PC and the Nintendo Switch in Q3 2022

The story-driven ARPG “No Place for Bravery” is coming to PC and the Nintendo Switch in Q3 2022

Press release: The UK/Singapore-based indie games publisher Ysbryd Games and Brazil-based indie game[...]
“El Hijo - A Wild West Tale” is now available for iOS and Android devices

“El Hijo - A Wild West Tale” is now available for iOS and Android devices

Press release: Giebelstadt, Germany, 25th January 2022. The international publisher of video games H[...]
“Aztech Forgotten Gods” is coming to PC and consoles on March 10th, 2022

“Aztech Forgotten Gods” is coming to PC and consoles on March 10th, 2022

Press release: Chihuahua, Mexico — Jan. 25, 2022. The Mexico-based indie games developer/publisher L[...]
The anime MMORPG “Grand Fantasia” has just kicked-off its Lunar New Year in-game festivities

The anime MMORPG “Grand Fantasia” has just kicked-off its Lunar New Year in-game festivities

Press release: Hamburg, Germany - January 25th, 2022. The Lunar New Year is upon us, and "Grand Fant[...]
NACON and Cyanide is kicking off the closed beta for "Blood Bowl 3" today

NACON and Cyanide is kicking off the closed beta for "Blood Bowl 3" today

Press release: Lesquin, 25 January 2022. NACON and the development studio Cyanide are pleased to ann[...]

Our sponsors

Kinguin
Booty calls via Nutaku
TGG v2.4 © 2014 - 2019 *The Gaming Ground* all rights reserved
twitch icon youtube icon google plus icon twitter icon facebook icon rss icon
alexa
Privacy policy
TGG ethics policies